Book Review: Just for the Plot by Meghan Quinn

Just for the Plot (Bay Area Players, #2)Just for the Plot by Meghan Quinn
Publisher: Bloom Books
Publication Date: May 5, 2026
My rating: 4.25 of 5 stars

Publisher’s Description:

They’re just friends.

At least, that’s what she thinks. Him? He has other plans.

Bennett Brinkman is San Francisco baseball’s golden boy―focused, disciplined, and very bad at ignoring the one woman he shouldn’t want. Falling for his sister’s best friend was inevitable, even though she’s always seen him as safe, familiar, and firmly off-limits.

Bower knows exactly why wanting Bennett is a terrible idea. She’s fiercely loyal to her best friend and well aware that crossing this particular line could blow everything up. But when she moves into Bennett’s apartment building, that “just friends” boundary begins to blur in the most tempting ways.

The banter comes fast.

The sparks come faster.

And pretending it’s “no big deal” is getting ridiculous.

As feelings get messier and attraction turns undeniable, Bennett and Bower must decide if risking their family ties is worth chasing the love that’s been in front of them all along.

The second book in the new Bay City Players series follows baseball player Bennett. He’s had a crush on his older sister’s best friend, Bower, for years, but she still sees him as the little brother of her best friend Gabby. She made a promise to Gabby when they were growing up that she would help Gabby protect him and that she would never get involved with Bennett in a romantic way.

Things get complicated when Bower moves from Almond Bay (that’s an older series that I haven’t read yet.) to Bennett’s apartment building in San Francisco for her job. It’s impossible for Bennett to ignore his feelings for her when she’s in such close proximity. Bower realizes Bennett is no longer a little boy – he’s fully grown and very hot. But she can’t act on her feelings because of her promise to Gabby. The fact that they have started a bookclub for just the two of them that only reads spicy romance does not help their situation.

In Just for the Plot, most of Meghann Quinn’s trademark banter is between the Gladdy Daddies, a Ted Lasso Diamond Dogs type group formed by Bennett and his two best friends to discuss problems with their love lives. Bower and Bennett’s interactions with each other were pretty serious most of the time.

I enjoyed this book, but it did get repetitive with Bower constantly breaking up with Bennett because of feeling guilty about breaking her promise to Gabby. However, the spice was top notch and high on the spice meter.

I’ll definitely read the next book in the series, which I’m thinking will be OC’s book with PR agent Gretchen being his love interest but that hasn’t been confirmed by Meghan yet.

Recommended of course!

Other books I’ve reviewed by Meghan Quinn:

The Wedding Game
How My Neighbor Stole Christmas
Til Summer Do Us Part
Just for the Cameras
Rules for the Summer